132: Hiya's "Fits Any Routine" Ad: Why the Boring Ad Might Be the Best Performer

No bold claims. No clever copy. Just three arrows and a product shot. That's the point.

Hey everyone, Chase here.

Most ad breakdowns celebrate the clever stuff — the unexpected hook, the pattern interrupt, the viral-worthy creative.

Today I want to talk about an ad that does none of that.

Hiya's sunscreen ad is: two hands holding a product, three callouts with arrows, and a headline that says "Fits Any Routine."

It looks like something an intern made in Canva.

And it might be outperforming every "creative" ad in their account.

What you'll learn:

• Why objection-killer ads often beat desire-creator ads in mid/bottom funnel

• The three questions every parent has about kids' sunscreen (and how Hiya answers all of them)

• When to stop trying to be clever and just be clear

Let's break it down.

This ad isn't creating desire. It's removing friction.

Most ads try to make you want something you didn't know you wanted.

This ad assumes you already want it. You're a parent. You know your kid needs sunscreen. That's not the question.

The question is: will this be a hassle?

Hiya's ad exists to answer that question three times:

• "Mess-free, rubs in easily" → Will application be a fight?

• "Compact tin fits in a bag" → Can I actually carry this?

• "Perfect for beach, park, or school days" → Does this work for my real life?

Every callout addresses a friction point. Not a benefit. Not a feature. A worry.

This is objection-killer creative. It doesn't persuade. It reassures.

The hands matter more than you think.

Notice: this isn't a flat product shot. It's two hands actually holding the open and closed tin.

That's a small detail with big impact.

Hands-on-product shows use. It helps you visualize yourself using it. The open tin shows you the texture of the sunscreen. The closed tin shows you how compact it is.

You're not looking at a product. You're seeing a moment — the moment you're about to apply sunscreen to your kid.

Demonstration beats description. Showing someone interacting with the product is more persuasive than describing what the product does.

The headline is boring on purpose.

"Kids Daily Sunscreen. Fits Any Routine."

There's no hook here. No pattern interrupt. No curiosity gap.

Just a clear statement of what the product is and why it works.

That's the right choice for this ad's job.

This ad isn't running to cold audiences who've never heard of Hiya. It's running to parents who've already visited the site, already considered buying, and just need one more nudge.

For that audience, clarity beats cleverness. They don't need to be entertained. They need their last question answered.

Every week I break down what makes ads & creative work.

CreativeOS is where you go to actually build them.

20,000+ templates. AI that learns your taste. A creative engine that gets smarter every time you use it.

It's the platform behind the newsletter.

Try CreativeOS → — use code CREATIVEDISCIPLINE for 25% off your first month.

Funnel position determines format.

Here's the key insight: the same brand needs different ads for different audiences.

Hiya probably has very different creative running for cold traffic — maybe UGC testimonials, maybe problem-aware hooks about chemical sunscreens, maybe lifestyle content showing active kids.

This ad is for warm traffic. People who already know the brand, already understand the category, already want to buy but have lingering questions.

For warm traffic, you don't need to sell the dream. You need to answer: "yeah, but will it actually work for my life?"

"Mess-free." "Fits in a bag." "Beach, park, or school days."

Questions answered. Friction removed. Purchase completed.

When to run objection-killer ads.

This format works when:

1. Your audience is already aware of the category. You're not educating them on why they need sunscreen. They know. You're just telling them why this sunscreen fits their life.

2. Your product has obvious friction points. Kids' sunscreen has real objections: mess, portability, application hassle. If your product has known friction, address it directly.

3. You're retargeting warm audiences. Cold traffic needs inspiration. Warm traffic needs reassurance. Match the creative to the temperature.

If you're running cold traffic acquisition, this ad will underperform. It doesn't create desire. It assumes desire. Know the difference.

What this teaches us about Creative Discipline

Not every ad needs to be clever.

Hiya's ad is simple, clear, and functional. It does exactly one job: answer the three questions a considering parent has in their head.

That's discipline.

The lesson: Know what job your ad needs to do. If the job is "remove friction for warm audiences," you don't need a hook. You need clarity.

Some of your best-performing ads won't be the ones you're proudest of creatively. They'll be the ones that answered the right question at the right moment.

Stop trying to win awards. Start trying to answer questions.

How to Apply This Week

1. List the top 3 objections your customers have. What do they worry about before purchasing? What questions come up in reviews or support tickets?

2. Build an ad that answers all three. No hook. No cleverness. Just three callouts that remove friction.

3. Run it to warm audiences. Retargeting, site visitors, email subscribers. See if simple clarity outperforms creative complexity.

Keep Creating,

Chase

P.S. — Sign up for our events calendar so you can get access to all the experts we work with helping you build your creative intelligence in real time.